Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Champions League Preview with Jimmy Conrad

I disagree with Brian Burke by being even more Burke than Burke is

All due respect to Brian Burke, I believe he is wrong about one thing. The quote:

Maple Leafs GM Brian Burke isn't a fan of Kovalchuk-like contracts - ProHockeyTalk - Hockey - NBC Sports
"No one is going to be able to prove circumvention until one of these guys retires," the Leafs GM said. "And by then we'll be in a new CBA. But I'm comfortable that a number of these players are, in fact, going to walk. "I don't believe these players are going to play in their mid-40s. And I don't believe they're going to play for what they're making in those final years. So it defies logic. It may not defy the CBA. But it defies logic to think that players are going to serve the term of all these contracts . So that's why we don't do them. And a number of teams don't do them. If the league thinks that this is one that they need to look into, then we support that."

That assumes that the only way to prove circumvention is to demonstrate that this one guy (Kovalchuk) will retire before he gets to the end of his contract. Obviously, one can't prove that Kovalchuk will not play till he's 44 anymore than one can prove Kovalchuk is not immortal. Yet the argument, "we just don't know if he's immortal, we will have to wait and see what happens," as the basis of an employment contract that extends to the end of time, is incontrovertibly stupid. And we wouldn't have to wait till the end of time (or his death) to prove it either.

More this afternoon...

Comment 4 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Jewels From The Crown

Trade Deadline Conversation Starters

Feb 2012 by Quisp - 46 comments

Inventory of Thanks

Nov 2011 by Quisp - 12 comments

Richards' Choices

Jul 2011 by Quisp - 25 comments

Comments

Display:

That's the famous Sergio Leone portrait photo of Burke, right?

Seriously, it has always struck me as intuitive and common-sensical that these front-loaded contracts are circumventions of the CBA. We didn’t used to have them before the current CBA, and now we do. What has changed? Duh.

I have some sympathy for those who protest that the league didn’t punish the Hawks for the Hossa contract, so why should the Devils be punished for Kovalchuk. But again, common sense should make it obvious that there is some difference in degree.

by DougX on Jul 27, 2010 11:20 AM PDT reply actions  

he new CBA will be interesting, either they’ll be exact contract limits in length at a certain age, or more than likely the Cap Hit won’t be the average of the contract, but that years salary.

by Throwdeuce5150 on Jul 27, 2010 11:42 AM PDT reply actions  

Burke is absolutely correct. There is absolutely no way a guy who has 100m dollars, and made 10m a year in his prime is going to be slogging around the ice at the age of 40+ for 550k a year, literally risking life and limb.

There are a number of ways to close this loophole, in fact over at broadstreethockey lindbergh31 proposed a pretty simple and effective method to stop these circumventions, which would be to stipulate a maximum variance in any one year from the cap hit, which could be 30-50%. That would easily eliminate the practice of tacking on low cost years at the contract end purely to lower the cap hit.

by Gizmoitus on Jul 27, 2010 2:42 PM PDT reply actions  

just set the max like this:

age / max length

22 / 12
23 / 11
24 / 10
25 / 9
26 / 8
27 / 7
28 / 6
29 / 5
30 / 4
31 / 4
32 / 4
33 / 4
34 / 3
35 / 3
36 / 3
37 / 2
38 / 2
39+ / 1

Wait till this year.

by Quisp on Jul 27, 2010 8:43 PM PDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Is it time to stop lurking and jump into the conversation? YES!

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Snpy_small
8-1 Playoff Starts

Recent FanPosts

Male-lion_small
Pac West Eternal Thread #1 We are a go! Maybe?
Nike_o_small
Interesting existence of Kings fan in Portland
Shock5_small
Great Moments In Illegal Ryane Clowe Poke Checking History
Small
....and Toffoli
Small
Schenn & Simmonds....
Snpy_small
What does it mean for the Kings when the Coyotes move?
Small
Kings College Prospects
Sam_0081_small
Venting Time!!
Jack_s_helmit_small
Pull the trigger or holster the GUN!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Manager

Pumpernicholl_small Niesy

Editors

Icon_crop_3_small Quisp

Eazy-e-color_small Robert_P.

Uncle_nick_s_avatar_small defrim65

Authors

Cima-avatar_small John Carroll